42
The
Body
Electric
half of the previous stock of determiners, until in the adult each cell
possessed only one. Muscle cells contained only the muscle determiner,
nerve cells only the one for nerves, and so on. This meant that once a cell's
function had been fixed, it could never be anything but that one kind of cell.
In one of his first experiments, published in 1888, Roux obtained
powerful support for this concept. He took fertilized frog eggs, which
were large and easy to observe, and waited until the first cell division
had occured. He then separated the two cells of this incipient embryo,
According to the theory,
each cell contained enough determiners to
make half an embryo, and that was exactly what Roux got—two half-
embryos.
It was hard to argue with such a clear-cut result, and the
determiner theory was widely accepted. Its triumph was a climactic vic-
tory for mechanistic concept of life, as well.
One of vitalism's last gasps came from the work of another German
embryologist, Hans Driesch. Initially a firm believer in Entivicklungs-
mechanik, Driesch later found its concepts deficient in the face of life's
continued mysteries. For example, using sea urchin eggs, he repeated
Roux's famous experiment and obtained a whole organism instead of a
half. Many other experiments convinced Driesch that life had some spe-
cial innate drive,
a process that went against known physical laws.
Drawing on the ancient Greek idea of the anima, he proposed a non-
material, vital
factor that he called entelechy. The beginning of the
twentieth century wasn't a propitious time for such an idea, however,
and it wasn't popular.
Mechanics of Growth
As the nineteenth century drew to a close and the embryologists con-
tinued to struggle with the problems of inheritance, they found they
still needed a substitute for the homunculus. Weismann's determiners
worked fine for embryonic growth, but regeneration was a glaring excep-
tion, and one that didn't prove the rule. The original theory had no
provision for a limited replay of growth to replace a part lost after devel-
opment was finshed. Oddly enough, the solution had already been pro-
vided by a man almost
totally
forgotten
today,
Theodor
Heinrich
Boveri.
Working at the University of Munich in the 1880s, Boveri discovered
almost every
detail of cell division, including the chromosomes. Not
until the invention of the electron microscope did anyone add meterially
to his original descriptions. Boveri found that all nonsexual cells of any